Money

Don't skewer super for a house

Noel Whittaker
Noel Whittaker

BUYING that first home is never easy, and ideas to help young people get ahead  are floated continually.  The latest one is changing the rules to allow young people to use their superannuation as house deposit.

Apart from driving up house prices the plan has two other major faults - it ignores the true cost of home ownership and the real purpose of superannuation.

First, there is a hefty margin between the costs of renting and owning. Take a house worth $400 000 that rents at $400 a week. The tenant gets occupancy for a total yearly cost of  $20,800 - in contrast, a mortgage of $350,000 will cost at least $24,500 a year in interest alone. Then add at least $3000 a year for rates and maintenance. This means that the tenant is almost $7000 a year better off than the owner.

Obviously renters who cannot save, could end up with serious financial problems if they somehow wrangle enough money for a home deposit.

Superannuation has one major goal - to provide people with a retirement income so they won't be living on the streets in their old age when the government runs out of welfare money. How much you have when you retire depends on three factors, The amount contributed, the rate earned, and the time the money was in there. Reduce any of these and you reduce the final payout.

Suppose two people invest $3000 a year for 40 years. If one earns five percent p.a. and the other earns 10 percent p.a, the end benefits are $400 000 and $1.6 million respectively. Just doubling the rate of return quadruples the end benefit. 

This example shows that that the primary objective of anybody with superannuation is to achieve the highest returns possible - you could never achieve this if you borrow money from your superannuation account and use it to reduce your home loan.

Noel Whittaker is a co-founder of Whittaker Macnaught Pty Ltd.  His advice is general in nature and readers should seek their own professional advice before making any financial decisions.  His email is noelwhit@gmail.com

Topics:  first home buyers, interest rates, mortgage, noel whittaker, superannuation


Stay Connected

Update your news preferences and get the latest news delivered to your inbox.

Ready to fight fire ignorance

A past bushfire along Eumundi Rd fuelled by strong northerly winds.

Eumundi fire risk workshop

Beyond 30s giving hope

Life Beyond 30 founder Wendy Wilson - in need of a helping hand.

Noosa helper needs help

Latest deals and offers

High acclaim for Cooroy's Long Tan tribute

Cooroy's Long Tan tribute may go on road

Ready to fight fire ignorance

A past bushfire along Eumundi Rd fuelled by strong northerly winds.

Eumundi fire risk workshop

Beyond 30s giving hope

Life Beyond 30 founder Wendy Wilson - in need of a helping hand.

Noosa helper needs help

Skuse's surprise G-G medal

Governor General Sir Peter Cosgrove makes a special award to Pam Skuse of Mision Mexico.

Former Noosa couple honoured

Celebrate craft beer on Saturday

The Noosa Craft Beer Festival is back tomorrow

73 live acts in festival teaser

Acts to play five venues over eight weeks

Muster fans disappointed after US comedian cuts show short

American country music comedian Rodney Carrington will play the Gympie Muster this weekend.

RODNEY Carrington performed about a third of his show last night.

What's on the small screen this week

Bella Frizza in a scene from the TV series Married At First Sight.

THE Block's $65,000 bathroom is revealed and strangers marry.

MOVIE REVIEW: Life on the Road

Ricky Gervais, Ben Bailey Smith and Foregone Conclusion (Steve Clarke, Andy Burrows, Stuart Baxter Wilkinson, Michael Clarke) in a scene from David Brent: Life on the Road.

Ricky Gervais has brought David Brent back to life on the big screen

Jessica Alba wants tequila shots served at her funeral

Businesswoman and actor Jessica Alba

There won't be mourning at this funeral

Tom Hiddleston's Instagram account hacked

Actor Tom Hiddleston

Thor star the latest celebrity targetted by hackers

Charlize Theron's son dresses up as Frozen character

Actor Charlize Theron

Star's son spotted dressed a beloved Frozen character

Don't fence us in: Boomers keep housing options open

White Picket Fence

No one-size-fits all solution for retiree housing, expert says

Why 93-year-old 'bachelor' Paul prefers to keep his pad

Paul Pariscos.  Photo: John McCutcheon / Sunshine Coast Daily

Paul Pariscos calls his unit at Maroochydore a bachelor pad

Is this the Coast's finest real estate?

These houses are nothing short of amazing.

Check out the photos of homes that few of us know anything about

Pat Rafter isn't the only star selling up

STAR: Pat Rafter.

Can you guess who else is going to the market in Noosa?

REVEALED: Pat Rafter's $18m Coast house on the market

Check out the photos of the Coast's most expensive property for sale

The "correction we had to have" in Gladstone's rentals

UPWARD MARCH: The rental vacancy rate in Gladstone has improved for the first time in more than a year, providing a confidence boost in the market.

Vacancy rates improve with signs that things are getting betterF