Money

Don't skewer super for a house

Noel Whittaker
Noel Whittaker

BUYING that first home is never easy, and ideas to help young people get ahead  are floated continually.  The latest one is changing the rules to allow young people to use their superannuation as house deposit.

Apart from driving up house prices the plan has two other major faults - it ignores the true cost of home ownership and the real purpose of superannuation.

First, there is a hefty margin between the costs of renting and owning. Take a house worth $400 000 that rents at $400 a week. The tenant gets occupancy for a total yearly cost of  $20,800 - in contrast, a mortgage of $350,000 will cost at least $24,500 a year in interest alone. Then add at least $3000 a year for rates and maintenance. This means that the tenant is almost $7000 a year better off than the owner.

Obviously renters who cannot save, could end up with serious financial problems if they somehow wrangle enough money for a home deposit.

Superannuation has one major goal - to provide people with a retirement income so they won't be living on the streets in their old age when the government runs out of welfare money. How much you have when you retire depends on three factors, The amount contributed, the rate earned, and the time the money was in there. Reduce any of these and you reduce the final payout.

Suppose two people invest $3000 a year for 40 years. If one earns five percent p.a. and the other earns 10 percent p.a, the end benefits are $400 000 and $1.6 million respectively. Just doubling the rate of return quadruples the end benefit. 

This example shows that that the primary objective of anybody with superannuation is to achieve the highest returns possible - you could never achieve this if you borrow money from your superannuation account and use it to reduce your home loan.

Noel Whittaker is a co-founder of Whittaker Macnaught Pty Ltd.  His advice is general in nature and readers should seek their own professional advice before making any financial decisions.  His email is noelwhit@gmail.com

Topics:  first home buyers, interest rates, mortgage, noel whittaker, superannuation


Join the Community.

Get your local news, your way.

Stay Connected

Update your news preferences and get the latest news delivered to your inbox.

New councillors ready to start work

NEWCOMERS will be assigned their roles within council this Thursday

Sailors defend title in China

Maryborough Easter Sailing Regatta - 125's Swish and Oddly Enough. Photo: Alistair Brightman / Fraser Coast Chronicle

A team of sailors from the Noosa Yacht & Rowing Club left for China

Green Army to head to Kin Kin

GREEN ARMY: The Green Army participant Michael Helerdine maintaining the trees in the Barolin Nature Reserve. Photo: Max Fleet / NewsMail

Six Mile and Kin Kin catchments are about to face a green invasion

Latest deals and offers

Playford reviewing system to stem council complaints

Retired mayor Noel Playford is to form a local government review panel to ensure complaints against serving councillors are handled in a transparent manner.

New councillors ready to start work

NEWCOMERS will be assigned their roles within council this Thursday

Sailors defend title in China

Maryborough Easter Sailing Regatta - 125's Swish and Oddly Enough. Photo: Alistair Brightman / Fraser Coast Chronicle

A team of sailors from the Noosa Yacht & Rowing Club left for China

Green Army to head to Kin Kin

GREEN ARMY: The Green Army participant Michael Helerdine maintaining the trees in the Barolin Nature Reserve. Photo: Max Fleet / NewsMail

Six Mile and Kin Kin catchments are about to face a green invasion

Flood map reveals Noosa’s future

The coastal flood mapping for Noosa Heads.

Noosa flood maps from climate change revealed

Noosa Council set to fly rainbow flag

Event organiser Robin Bristow with Noosa Shire Councillor Frank Wilkie. Photo Sophie Meixner / Buderim Chronicle

Noosa will be flying the rainbow flag for equal rights.

Jet ski event a sight to see

Brock Taylor will compete at King of Freeride.

Flips, tricks and barrels at jet ski event.

ACF take Minister to Court

ACF chief executive Kelly O'Shanassy

The Australian Conservation Foundation go to court to stop Carmichael mine.

Dash Cam: Roo takes on car

Kangaroo leaps car.

Kangaroo could have kept going, jumps car instead.

Glenn Tidyman walks free

Glenn Brian Tidyman, 43, leaves Maroochydore Watch House after being granted bail on charges of common assault and entering a dwelling with intent by break at night using violence.

Glenn Brian Tidyman, walks free from Maroochydore Watch House after being granted...

Jail for real estate boss

Noosaville real estate agent boss will spend 14 months in jail

Demand for acreage lots pushes up property prices

Property values in Cooroy have increased 25%

Property values jump in Cooroy and Peachester.

How a sacked real estate agent made $725k in four months

Agent is now under investigation by the industry watchdog