Wife’s dark mother and son sex suspicion
The wife who found her husband having sex with his mother on their couch says she always suspected something between them and reveals the very similar way their own romance began.
Lori Lavoie walked in on her naked mother-in-law, 63, Cheryl Lavoie, on top of her also naked husband having intercourse on the couch in the Fitchburg, Massachusetts, boarding house where all three live.
Tony Lavoie Jnr, 43, later told police the sex "just happened" after they began kissing while playing a video game and then removing each other's clothes, but claimed that it had not happened before.
However Lori Lavoie told Fitchburg Officer Mark Kaddy who attended the scene she "always had suspicions of the two of them having an intimate relationship".
Lori, who according to her Facebook page is separated from Tony despite the fact they still lived under the same roof, said she wanted Cheryl removed from the home.
In a statement by Officer Kaddy, Lori also revealed an intimate allegation about the mother and son, but told him she didn't have any proof and it was just something she had heard.
The alleged incestuous act between Cheyl Lavoie and her son Tony Lavoie Jnr dates back to the evening of Tuesday May 19 this year, but only emerged at a court hearing on August 20.
They face up to 20 years in prison if convicted.
Officer Kaddy was dispatched to 137 Clarendon Street, Fitchburg, a mountain railroad town 100km northwest of Boston around 8.30pm for "a report of a disturbance between multiple parties".
At the dwelling's entrance, Officer Kaddy found Lori's cousin Joan who stated "she was told from Lori Lavoie that Lori's husband Tony Lavoie was caught having sex with his biological mother Cheryl Lavoie".
When the officer asked Joan if he could speak to any of the involved parties she said "yes they are all inside".
After asking Lori to step outside she told Officer Kaddy "that she walked in on her husband Tony Lavoie having sex with his mother Cheryl Lavoie in the living room".
Officer Kaddy's report says he then asked Lori an intimate question about the extent of the sexual activity to which she agreed.
"Lori then stated that she saw her mother-in-law Cheryl Lavoie was naked on top of her husband Tony Lavoie having sex," he said in a police report.
Asked what she did after witnessing this, Lori said "I walked into my room and closed the door".
She said nothing to her husband or mother-in-law, "went to my room and called my cousin then the police".
Lori then disclosed to the officer her long-held suspicion about the mother and son.
Officer Kaddy then asked Tony Lavoie Jnr to step outside and tell him what had happened.
Tony Jnr said: "I don't want to talk about it, I made a mistake and I am embarrassed enough as it is".
When Officer Kaddy told Tony Jnr his wife had stated she had caught him having sex with his biological mother, he replied, "Yes we did have sex, it just happened".
When Officer Kaddy asked Mr Lavoie how it had "just happened", he replied "I don't know it just happened".
When the officer asked Mr Lavoie the same intimate question he had asked Lori about the extent of the activity, he agreed it had been to that extent.
Officer Kaddy states in his report, "I asked him if they had clothes on and he said 'no we took off each other's clothes'."
The officer then asked Mr Lavoie if it was the first time this had happened and he replied, "yes this is the first time we have ever done anything like this".
He then said the sex was consensual between both him and his mother Cheryl.
Officer Kaddy again asked him if it was the first time and he again stated that it was.
The officer said Mr Lavoie "did not seem to be nervous or upset about having sex with Cheryl Lavoie" just "more embarrassed about getting caught by his wife".
Mr Lavoie then told the officer he had been playing a video game in the living room "when he and his mother just started to kiss and have sex".
At this point, the policeman noted, Mr Lavoie "began to become defensive … that it was just a mistake … he didn't want to talk it much more … he wanted to get treatment".
Officer Kaddy then asked to speak with Cheryl Lavoie and Mr Lavoie went inside to get his mother.
When he asked Cheryl what happened she replied "well myself and my son got caught by Lori".
Asked if that meant they got caught having sex, Cheryl replied "Yes we did I was on top of my son on the couch".
Cheryl agreed the sex was consensual.
When asked how it came about she said "well myself and my son have gotten a lot closer over the last few months and we just had sex after we were kissing".
Asked if she felt pressured into having sex, Cheryl said "no" and admitted she was "naked on the couch on top of him" and "we took off each other's clothes".
Asked it was the first time having sex with her son, she said it was and confirmed the extent of the sexual activity.
The officer inquired about Mr Lavoie's possible mental illness and Cheryl said she didn't know because he hadn't been with her for most of his life.
She said he "did fall off a ladder at one point in his life".
Fitchburg police charged Cheryl Lavoie and Tony Lavoie Jnr with felony incest for having sexual contact with a prohibited relationship of mother and son.
Last week, both were arraigned and placed on personal recognisance release and ordered not to contact one another.
They will return to Fitchburg District Court on October 27 for a pre-trial hearing and could face up to 20 years in state prison.
Lori Lavoie posted on Facebook three years ago that she had met Tony Lavoie on a snowy evening in December in 2011 when she was leaving a theatre show.
"He walked me to my black jeep pulled me to him and kissed me. Ever since then he has had my heart," she wrote.
But a Facebook post two days ago asks people to recognise that she is separated from him.
Originally published as Wife's dark mother and son sex suspicion